Table of Contents
- How appraisers value a garage
- Is a converted garage counted as living space?
- Permitted vs. unpermitted garage conversions
- What an appraiser checks on a converted garage
- What losing the garage parking does to value
- Garage to ADU conversions in California
- Should you convert your garage?
- Frequently asked questions
A garage is worth what buyers in that neighborhood pay for one, and an appraiser measures that from comparable sales, not from a set dollar figure. A garage is not counted as living area. It shows up as its own line on the appraisal, and the appraiser adjusts each comparable sale up or down for having more or fewer parking spaces than the home being appraised.
A converted garage is harder. Its value depends on whether the work was permitted, how well it was done, and whether buyers in the area want the extra room more than the parking.
How appraisers value a garage
The appraisal report lists the garage under car storage: how many spaces, and whether it is attached, detached or built in. That area is never added to the home's gross living area (GLA).
In the sales comparison grid, the appraiser compares the garage to the garages at each comparable sale. If a comparable has a two-car garage and the subject has a one-car garage, that comparable gets an adjustment. The size of the adjustment comes from local market evidence, such as two similar homes that sold for different prices mainly because one had a garage.
That is why there is no national answer to "how much is a garage worth." In a neighborhood where parking is easy and few homes have garages, the adjustment may be small. Where street parking is hard to find, buyers often pay much more for one.
Is a converted garage counted as living space?
Sometimes. For loans sold to Fannie Mae, appraisers measure homes under the ANSI Z765 standard. Under that standard, finished area has to be enclosed, suitable for year-round use, and finished with walls, floors and ceilings similar to the rest of the house.
A garage turned into a heated room with drywall, real flooring and a normal entry door can meet that test. A space with a bare concrete floor and the roll-up door still in place usually reads as a finished garage, not living space.
Meeting the physical test is only the first step. The appraiser still has to decide what buyers would pay for the space, and that comes down to permits, quality and what is typical in the area.
Permitted vs. unpermitted garage conversions
A permitted conversion, done by a professional and common in the neighborhood, is the easiest case. It can be counted as living area and compared with sales of homes that have similar space.
An unpermitted conversion does not automatically count for nothing. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide (B4-1.3-05) says that when an appraiser finds an addition without the required permit, the appraiser must comment on the quality and appearance of the work and its impact, if any, on market value. Some lenders add stricter rules of their own, such as leaving unpermitted space out of GLA.
In Austin Fernald's practice, most converted garages end up valued as a garage. An attached garage converted without permits is usually treated as garage space. A rough, unpermitted conversion with the door removed may be worth little more than storage.
What an appraiser checks on a converted garage
- Structural changes. Was the garage door removed, were walls framed in, were windows or sliding doors added?
- Permits and workmanship. Did the owner pull permits and hire a licensed contractor?
- Whether conversions are typical for the area, and how buyers react to them in recent sales.
- If the garage is now a separate unit, whether it is a legal unit under local zoning.
Owners can help by having permits, plans and contractor invoices ready. The home appraisal checklist lists the other records worth gathering.
What losing the garage parking does to value
Converting a garage adds a room while you own the home. The cost shows up when you sell. Some buyers will love the extra space, but many want a garage, and a home without one has fewer buyers to sell to.
How reversible the change is matters. Paint, a rug and some furniture in a garage that still has its door are easy to undo, and a buyer can park there again. Removing the door, pouring a raised floor or adding plumbing is not, and buyers price in the cost of turning it back.
Many owners who convert have a detached garage and a long driveway, and they already park outside. In that setting the loss of covered parking may matter less to buyers. Sellers who want to know before listing can order a pre-listing appraisal.
Garage to ADU conversions in California
Turning a garage into a permitted accessory dwelling unit (ADU) is often the strongest version of a conversion, because the space becomes a rentable home instead of a spare room. California's ADU law also helps with parking. Under Government Code section 66314(d)(11), when a garage, carport or covered parking structure is converted to an ADU, the city or county may not require the lost parking spaces to be replaced. The state's Department of Housing and Community Development publishes guidance on the rules.
The conversion still needs a building permit. That parking rule applies to ADUs, not to a garage turned into an extra bedroom or office, which falls under local zoning.
On the appraisal, an ADU is reported separately from the main house. Fannie Mae's guidelines say ADU living area is not added to the primary home's above-grade square footage unless the ADU is inside the home, has interior access and is above grade. Fannie Mae treats a home with a qualifying ADU as a one-unit property, not a duplex. The appraiser decides whether the second unit is an ADU or makes the home a two-unit property, based on things like separate meters, a separate address and whether it can legally be rented. Comparable sales that also have ADUs are preferred.
Should you convert your garage?
If the space is already just storage and you have room to park on the driveway, converting it can make sense for how you live. Go in expecting the appraisal to credit it closer to a garage than to new living area, unless it is permitted, well built and common in your neighborhood.
If the goal is resale value, check zoning first and consider a permitted ADU. A market value appraisal before you start shows what the home is worth as it stands. For more on which projects pay back, see how remodeling affects the appraisal.
Austin Fernald appraises homes with converted garages and ADUs across Marin County and San Francisco.
Frequently asked questions
Does a garage count as square footage in an appraisal?
No. Garage area is never included in gross living area. It is reported on its own line, and the appraiser adjusts for differences in garage spaces between the home and the comparable sales.
How much value does a garage add to a home?
It depends on the neighborhood. The appraiser measures it from local sales, so a garage can add a lot where parking is scarce and very little where most homes park in the driveway.
Does an unpermitted garage conversion hurt the appraisal?
Often it adds less than the owner expects. The appraiser must comment on the quality and appearance of unpermitted work and its effect on value, and some lenders will not count unpermitted space as living area without comparable sales that support it.
Does a garage converted to an ADU count as a second unit?
For Fannie Mae lending, a home with a qualifying ADU is usually a one-unit property; the appraiser makes that call. The ADU is described separately on the report and valued using comparable sales that also have ADUs.
How do I find out what my converted garage adds to my home's value?
An appraiser compares the home with recent local sales that have and don't have converted garages. The guide to reading an appraisal shows where the garage and the adjustments appear in the report.