RealVals

Do Home Appraisers Use Zillow?

See RealVals first in Google

Add us as a preferred source and our appraisal guides get a "preferred" badge in your AI Overviews and Top Stories.

Table of Contents
  1. What is a Zestimate?
    1. How accurate is a Zestimate?
  2. Zestimate vs appraisal
    1. Eppraisal vs Zillow
  3. Do home appraisers use Zillow?
  4. Where appraisers get their data
  5. The sales comparison approach
  6. When to use a Zestimate and when to get an appraisal

Home appraisers don't use Zillow to value a house. They may glance at a Zestimate or a listing page for background, but the value in an appraisal comes from MLS data, public records, the inspection and recent comparable sales the appraiser analyzes and adjusts.

A Zestimate is a computer estimate. An appraisal is a licensed appraiser's opinion of value, backed by a report that shows the work. Here is how the two compare and why they often disagree.

What is a Zestimate?

A Zestimate is Zillow's automatic estimate of a home's market value. Redfin, Realtor.com and Eppraisal publish their own versions. All of them are automated valuation models (AVMs): software that estimates value from public records, listing data and recent sales.

In broad terms they do what an appraiser does, comparing a home's size, rooms, lot and location with homes that sold nearby. The difference is that no one visits the house, checks the records or decides which sales really match.

How accurate is a Zestimate?

Zillow publishes its own accuracy figures. In fall 2026, Zillow put the nationwide median error at 1.77% for homes listed for sale and 7.20% for homes not on the market, and it updates these figures regularly (Zillow's Zestimate page). A median error means half of Zestimates miss by more than that.

On a $1,500,000 home that isn't for sale, a 7.2% miss is about $108,000. That's a typical miss, not a worst case.

AVMs do best in tract neighborhoods with a few floor plans and lots of recent sales. They struggle with one-of-a-kind homes, hillside lots, views, unpermitted additions and areas with few sales, which describes much of San Francisco and Marin County. They also can't see condition, so a gutted kitchen and a new one look the same to the software.

Zestimate vs appraisal

The two answer the same question in very different ways:

  • A Zestimate is free and instant. An appraisal costs a fee and takes days.
  • A Zestimate relies on whatever records exist for the home. An appraiser inspects the house and measures it.
  • A Zestimate picks comparable sales by algorithm. An appraiser chooses them and adjusts each one for differences.
  • A Zestimate doesn't show its work. An appraisal report lays out the comparables, the adjustments and the reasoning.
  • Lenders, courts and the IRS don't accept a Zestimate as an appraisal. Zillow itself says it isn't one.

How close is a Zestimate to an appraisal? Sometimes very close, especially for a listed home in a uniform neighborhood. For an off-market or unusual home, a gap bigger than that 7.2% median isn't surprising.

Eppraisal vs Zillow

Eppraisal and Zillow are both free online value estimators, and both are AVMs. Despite the name, an Eppraisal estimate isn't an appraisal either. The same goes for the Redfin Estimate.

Each site uses its own model and data, so the same house can show noticeably different numbers on each one. A wide spread between them is a sign the home is hard to value automatically.

Do home appraisers use Zillow?

Only as a starting point. When Austin Fernald, a California Certified Residential Appraiser, prepares a fee quote, he looks up the address online, and listing sites like Zillow and Redfin usually come up first. The estimates and listing details give a quick sense of the home's size and price range, which helps set the fee.

That's as far as any appraiser should take them. The value in the report comes from better data and a documented method.

Where appraisers get their data

Appraisers work mainly from the multiple listing service (MLS), the shared database real estate agents use for listings, sales and leases. An MLS record usually has far more detail than a public listing site, including agent-only remarks, sale and concession details, and sometimes floor plans or disclosures.

They also use county tax and deed records, building permits and their own notes from past inspections. When sources disagree, for example on square footage, the appraiser measures the house and explains which number the report uses.

The sales comparison approach

To value a house, an appraiser almost always relies on the sales comparison approach. They pick comparable sales as similar to your home as possible, ideally recent and close by.

Then they adjust each sale for differences. If a comparable has a bigger lot, an extra bathroom or a remodeled kitchen your house doesn't have, the appraiser subtracts from its price. If it's inferior, they add. The adjusted prices show what each sale would likely have brought if it were your house.

All of this sits in a grid in the report, one column per comparable, with every adjustment listed. How to read an appraisal walks through that grid line by line.

When to use a Zestimate and when to get an appraisal

A Zestimate is fine for curiosity or a rough range before you talk to an agent. When someone else will rely on the number, such as a lender, the IRS, a court or family members splitting an estate, you need an appraisal. Sellers who want an independent number before choosing a list price often order a pre-listing appraisal.

RealVals provides market value appraisals in San Francisco and Marin County, starting at $500 for a single-family home or condo. Austin inspects every home himself and sends a free quote within one business day.

Austin Fernald

Austin Fernald is a California Certified Residential Appraiser and the founder of RealVals. He covers San Francisco and Marin County in the Bay Area.